Why Dishwasher Machine Is Better than Maid? (Dishwasher Vs Maid) Total Calculations | Advantages | Disadvantages | Dishwasher Buying Guide

This is an interesting topic of discussion. We have to wash all our utensils every single day. We employ a maid for this duty and paying some fixed amount of money on a monthly basis. Finding an economical & affordable local housemaid is itself a challenge. And even if we find economical bai (maid) for this task, still we have to worry about whether the maid will come up the next day or not. Also, if she took a day off, we have to do all the work & tasks on our own anyway.

Comparison between the dishwasher and housemaid —
People used to search for; Is a dishwasher machine better than a maid? I am planning to buy a dishwasher & how is the experience with dishwashers in India? Are dishwashers worth buying in India? What are the pros and cons of using a dishwasher in India? How taking the dishwasher into the kitchen worth? And so on.


No doubt your maid does the same thing as the dishwasher, but there are many factors you need to consider to calculate everything. You must know all the things before buying dishwasher. I'm here to compare tons of points between maid and dishwasher. And I’m sure, this article will jiggle your mind.

Housemaid Calculations

I’m living in Pune city where maid wages are between 800 to 1000 Rs. per month for just utensils cleaning. For the family of 4 people.

Maid wages: Rs.800 x 12 months x 10 years = Rs.96,000

Detergents Cost

Bai requires detergents that we need to calculate as well;

1. Vim Bar - https://amzn.to/2BupleF at ~Rs.50/-
   
2. Vim Gel - https://amzn.to/31AwR2j at ~Rs.180/-
   
3. Pril Gel - https://amzn.to/33Nkgu0 at ~Rs.160/-
   

By considering the above rates for the Detergents like soap or liquid gel etc., it costs Rs.60 for a month.

Detergent cost: Rs.60 x 12 months x 10 years = Rs.7,200

Dishwasher Calculations

Here I'm considering a branded dishwasher in the market.

Bosch Dishwasher: https://amzn.to/3QxZ5XG
(Check above link for 2 years of comprehensive warranty + 10% Instant OFF offer)

Its energy consumption is 1.5 Kilowatts Hours (A kilowatt is 1000 times greater than a watt), this means, if we use this for an hour it will burn 1.5 units of power which cost approx. Rs.5/- per unit consumption.

Electricity Consumption

Let's first calculate how much electricity does a dishwasher uses per hour;

Time required: You need to run the dishwasher for an avg. 1 hour per day on max side.
So, the electricity/Power consumption calculated by,
1(hr.) x 1.5 (per unit) x 5 (unit charges) = Rs.7.5 daily.

So, Monthly dishwasher electricity usage: 7.5 x 30 = Rs.225

The dishwasher also want detergents that also we required to calculate as;
The brands available in the market specially made for dishwasher use are;

1. Fortune Dishwasher Kit [detergent + salt + rinse aid]: https://amzn.to/4dxC9lm.
   
2. Dishwasher Scent Tablets/Soap: https://amzn.to/4bsSsxR.

Daily detergent usage: Rs.10.
Monthly Detergent cost for dishwasher: Rs.300

Total monthly [electricity + detergent] cost: 225 + 300 = Rs.525
Yearly usage = 525 (Monthly) x 12 (months) = Rs.6300

Dishwasher Vs Bai: Reality

From the above calculations its seen that the dishwasher is much better than a bai.

But you also need to consider the initial cost for a bai is ZERO whereas for the dishwasher you have to pay 30000 as a one-time investment.

So total dishwasher expenses will be 63000 + 30000 = Rs.93000.

Wait, the game is not yet finished. 🤞

In a real scenario, once you have a dishwasher in your home, you will not run it daily. According to my own experience, at max. we run it 3 times in a week. So it affects the total calculations as per the real time use as;
12 times per month x 7.5 = Rs.90
So the yearly electricity usage: 90 x 12 = Rs.1080
And 1080 x 10 = Rs.10,800 for 10 years

The detergent use also decreases as; 12 times use x Rs.10 per use x 12 months x 10 years = Rs.14,400

In real-time the actual dishwasher expenses are 10800 + 14400 = Rs 25,200 for 10 years.

Whereas in realtime, housemaid calculations = Rs. 1,03,200 for 10 years.

You also need to check more realtime scenes as shown below in the table.

Real time performance metrics comparison: Dishwasher Vs Maid

Check out the below table enlists important comparison points.

Comparison points	Housemaid	Dishwasher
Total Cost for 10 years	Rs.1,03,200	Rs.25,200
Family Size	4	4
Availability	Limited to specific hours only	24x7
Water usage	Approx. 40 liters every time	10 liters every time
Bonus	Rs.5,000 for 10 years e.g. Rs.500 per year like Diwali Bonus etc.	0
Sound/Noise	No need to say, you know it very well.	Silent, does the job with minimal noise.

Bottom Line

On top of that, whenever we instruct the housemaids to do this and that, then the time is wasted, & life is disturbed. The discussion with the maid soon became a debate and the maid always wins the war. Also, if we have guests in the house and our maid couldn’t turn up, we had to do this “cleaning” job on our own.

On the other side, the machine never complains, we can use it any time of the day. We don’t have to wait, it is there for us 24x7. It silently works, and we can do all our activities with peace of mind.

Anyways, I hope this is enough information for you to re-think this “Dishwasher Vs Maid” topic. Still, if you would like to suggest or question anything on this, don’t hesitate to use the below comment section. Happy to hear from you.

Dont forget to SHARE this page with your friends via Facebook and WhatsApp.